nakhweh.org / Guides

What was unclear on your first shift? A three-question feedback card

· · Worked example and worksheet

The coordinator points to a shelf of donated books and says, “Start sorting here.” Half an hour later, a new volunteer is still holding a damaged book. They know what the job is. They do not know who decides what to do with this one. A single rating of the whole orientation would make that distinction hard to see.

1. Choose a decision you can change before the next shift

For the book-sorting team, the decision is what to put on the welcome sheet. Start with the task and contact role already named in the volunteer project brief. If nobody is assigned to answer questions about damaged items, fix that gap before asking volunteers to rate the instructions.

NCVO’s induction guidance asks organizers to check that volunteers understand what is expected. For this shift, show the new volunteer the damaged-book tray and introduce the person who decides what goes in it.

2. Copy these questions onto a card

Heading: Help us improve the next welcome. You can skip any question. Please leave out names and personal details. Give volunteers a separate way to speak privately with the coordinator if they need an answer about their own shift.

  1. When your shift started, did you know which task to begin? Choose one: Yes / Partly / No / I have not started a task yet.
  2. If a task instruction was unclear, did you know whom to ask? Choose one: Yes / No / I have not needed to ask yet.
  3. What is one instruction you would add to the welcome sheet? One short phrase is enough. Leave it blank if nothing comes to mind.

The first two questions can produce different answers. Combining them into “Were your task and contact clear?” would hide which instruction needs attention. Pew Research Center explains this problem in its guide to writing survey questions. On a digital version, keep each question optional and check whether the form automatically records names or email addresses before describing how responses are handled.

3. Try the card before promising two minutes

Use two minutes as a design target. Ask someone unfamiliar with the card to try it on the paper or phone volunteers will actually use. Start when the heading appears and stop when they can hand it back or submit it. Ask which option, if any, was hard to choose. Record the elapsed time and the wording that caused the pause. A coordinator reading their own draft aloud measures a different task.

If the optional writing takes most of the time, try making the invitation shorter. If someone stopped because they had not begun a task, keep that answer available. Try the revised card again before printing a time estimate on it. People who need more time can take it.

4. Turn the answers into one repair

Suppose eight people were offered the fictional book-sorting card and five returned it. Four of the five marked “Yes” for knowing the first task. On the contact question, two marked “Yes,” two “No,” and one “I have not needed to ask yet.” Record those counts separately. Three people did not return a card, and nothing here establishes what those three knew.

The shift lead can add one line by the damaged-book tray: “Ask the sorting lead before placing a damaged book on a sale shelf.” Put the new sentence and its owner in the handover for the next coordinator. On the next shift, ask the contact question again and keep that shift’s totals on a separate row.

Download the feedback-card tally for the fictional example, including how many cards were offered, how many came back and how the answers were counted.

This new guide is independently maintained and is not issued by the former organization or authors. Related editorial guides are part of the same maintained collection.

Site policy
Analytics privacy
Microsoft Clarity / Privacy